Skip to main content

Climate Assessment Forecast: Agricultural Production to Decline in Midwest


“Projected changes in precipitation, coupled with rising extreme temperatures before mid-century, will reduce Midwest agricultural productivity to levels of the 1980s without major technological advances,” according to the Fourth National Climate Change Assessment.

Most media reports on the Fourth National Climate Change Assessment present the big picture for the future of the United States under a changing climate. In fact, it seems most reporters didn’t get past the Assessment’s Executive Summary.

April Baumgarten, a reporter for the Grand Forks Herald and the Forum News Service, seems to have been somewhat of an exception. The report is made up of 1,600 pages with 29 chapters. Ten of them focus on various regions of the U.S. Baumgarten studied the section on the Northern Great Plains for her December 16th article.

For purpose of the Climate Assessment, the Northern Great Plains’ eastern boundary is the Red River. So, seeking to add to Baumgarten’s study of the Assessment’s chapter on the Northern Great Plains, I studied the chapter on the Midwest with a focus on the section on agriculture.

The Midwest chapter also includes sections on Forestry, the Great Lakes, Transportation and Infrastructure, and others.

“By conservative estimates, the days that are projected to be above 90 degrees in North Dakota by the mid-21st century likely will increase by 10 to 25 days,” Baumgarten wrote. 

Minnesota, and the Midwest, haven’t been getting warmer but we have been getting less cold, according to the Assessment. Those of us who farm have noticed that over the years the date of the last spring frost has consistently been pushed further into what was once winter-like weather. The Assessment bears out our anecdotal experience.

“The last spring frost has occurred earlier, causing the frost-free season to increase by an average of nine days since 1901. However, daily maximum temperatures in summer in the Midwest have not followed the upward global trend, in part due to higher early summer rainfall on deep, water-holding soils, thereby avoiding plant stress detrimental to crops.”

Essentially, we’ve been having milder and shorter winters. Those milder winters have created an environment where certain pests and diseases have been able to thrive, according to research published in the scientific journals Global Change Biology and Nature Climate Change.

The rising average daily minimum temperature has also had the surprising effect of playing a role in reducing grain quality.

“Elevated growing-season minimum daily temperatures are considered a factor in reducing grain weight in corn due to increased night time plant respiration,” according to the Assessment.

But, in the future, the Midwest will not only be less cold but our region will start to catch up in the daily maximum temperatures department. 

Male flowers on corn plant - Wikipedia

“Current average annual 5-day maximum temperature values range from about 88°F in Northern Minnesota to 97°F in Southern Missouri,” according to the Assessment. “5-day maximum temperatures are projected to have moved further above optimum conditions for many crops and closer to the reproductive failure temperature, especially for corn in the southern half of the Midwest. Higher growing-season temperatures also shorten phenological stages in crops (for example, the grain fill period for corn). Under these temperatures, overall yield trends will be reduced because of periodic pollination failures and reduced grain fill during other years.” (The following tables, from the Assessment, demonstrate what happens to crops when it gets too hot.)


Table 21.1: Average Annual 5-Day Maximum Temperature

Table 21.1: These modeled historical and projected average annual 5-day maximum temperatures illustrate the temperature increases projected for the middle of this century across the Midwest. 




Table 21.2: Optimum and Failure Temperatures for Vegetative Growth and Reproduction
Table 21.2: This table shows the temperatures at which corn and soybeans reach optimum growth and reproduction as well as the temperatures at which growth and reproduction fail



Baumgarten’s Grand Forks Herald article pointed out that climate change will have effects on other aspects of life in the Midwest and Great Plains. Ironically, she points out the oil production in North Dakota will become more expensive because of the growing scarcity of water.

“Finally, higher maximum temperatures, longer and more severe heat waves, and higher overnight lows are expected to increase electricity demand for cooling in the summer, further stressing the power grid,” she wrote.

You can read Baumgartens article here

The Fourth National Climate Change Assessment is here

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Senator Gazelka: Prepare for End Times

Review by John King “Marketplace Ministers are part of how the Lord will reach the peoples of the earth in these last days.” Author Paul Gazelka wrote this astonishing sentence near the conclusion of his 2003 book, Marketplace Ministers , but it is a good place to start here because it so neatly encapsulates the message of the book which is that business people, by spreading the Gospel, are in a unique position to prepare us, for the end of the world.   Gazelka, an insurance salesman in Baxter, Minnesota, devotes chapters one through four to the story of his religious calling and how he came to adopt the “marketplace” as his personal ministry.  He goes to some length, relying in part on the “Fivefold Path” from Ephesians to convince the reader that the marketplace is a legitimate pulpit to spread the Word.  The remainder of the book, using personal anecdotes and biblical passages, he explains how a marketplace ministry would function and what its usefulness w...

Super-emitting frequent fliers responsible for 50% of aviation CO2

U.S. airlines received a $15 billion subsidy in December’s COVID relief package. The subsidy was for the companies to re-employ thousands of their furloughed employees and keep them on the payroll until at least the end of the first quarter of this year. Congress, and the President, attached no other strings to the huge subsidy, even though airlines social costs, in terms of climate disruption, are huge. In 2018 airlines produced a billion tons of CO2 and benefited from a $100 billion subsidy by not paying for the climate damage they caused, a report published in the November 2020 journal Global Environmental Change, pointed out. The report, summarized in The Guardian on November 17th, drew together data to provide a global picture of the impact of frequent fliers. The conclusion reached by the study’s authors, led by Stefan Gössling at Linnaeus University in Sweden, is that a tiny fraction of the global population benefits from the highly subsidized airline industry while the rest...

Step aside Republicans; Minnesotans want electric vehicles

Late last month Senator Paul Gazelka, the Republican leader of the Senate, told the Minnesota Reformer that the Republican controlled Senate would likely fire the acting Commissioner of the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency, Laura Bishop, if the Agency, at the behest of the Governor, went ahead with the Clean Car Rule. The rule would require automakers to increase the number of electric vehicles they deliver to Minnesota auto dealers. Gazelka told The Reformer that he’d had “a conversation” with Bishop about the rule. Bishop has not been confirmed by the Senate. Gazelka, and his Republican colleagues, claim that electric vehicles are too expensive and that the rule would be a burden to Minnesotans. Gazelka, and the rest of his Party are wrong. They aren’t paying attention to the economics of EV ownership and they are not paying attention to consumer preferences. Way back in September 2019, Consumer Reports reported on a study of Minnesotans they had done in collaboration with the...